Perhaps no lure within the world of fantasy baseball entices owners more than the desire to discover the next big thing.
And, let's face it, if you are in a Dynasty League with a cheap Corey Seager or even Mike Trout, you are one step ahead of the rest of your league just within the context of your freeze list.
In fact, Mastersball releases our Top 250 Prospect List to facilitate just those selections for owners prepping for drafts in deeper leagues (note I am furiously working on the Top 250 now, and plan on an early December release as part of our Platinum Package).
Well, what if we got a league full of analysts who draft teams with just rookies, trying to anticipate who will not just get some time in 2017, but players who might have an impact?
Well, the braintrust at BBHQ wondered that very question, so as part of the presentation at First Pitch Arizona (FPAZ), we did just that. Eric Karabell, Eric Longenhagen, Clay Link, Chris Blessing, Jock Thompson, Jeff Zimmerman, Brian Walton and I selected 14-man rosters consisting of nine position players and five starting pitchers for a league that will indeed track our totals, sans saves. And, that means selecting the team with the most MLB playing time is going to have an advantage.
That meant choosing from among players who already seemed to have a job, if not playing time locked up, a la Alex Reyes or Hunter Renfroe in deference to the likes of Josh Hader, who has talent, who has nowhere to go but the Show, but who has to take advantage of the opportunity.
Round 1. Josh Hader (Brewers, P): My pick and sort of contrarian in that Alex Reyes--taken by my mate Brian Walton as the next pick--actually has a gig in the Cards rotation. But Hader, who has nothing else to prove in the Minors, has whiffed 11.5 batters per nine innings and clearly Taylor Jungmann is not going to be the dominant starter Hader can be.
Round 2. J.P. Crawford (Phillies, SS): Considering Crawford will be 22 in January, he did pretty well, hitting .244-4-30 at Lehigh Valley over 336 at-bats, with a .328 OBP. Over 406 minor league games, Crawford has a .278-25-154 line with 62 swipes and a great .372 OBP (232 walks to 243 strikeouts). Jeff Zimmerman thinks Crawford will be the Opening Day shortstop in the City of Brotherly Love.
Round 3. Robert Gsellman (Mets, P): The next in line from what seems like a limitless supply of hot new arms, Gsellman went 4-2, 2.42 over seven starts at Citi after going 4-9, 3.99 over 115 minor league frames split between Double-A and Triple-A. Gsellman ostensibly goes into the rotation, all of which told RotoWire's Clay Link that Gsellman was a smart play irrespective of how we pronounce his surname.
Round 4. Andrew Toles (Dodgers, OF): No question the Dodgers seem to have trouble getting and keeping outfielders healthy, such that Toles, who logged 105 plate appearances and then made some post-season play as well, has a shot to start at Dodger Stadium. Add in his nice .314-3-16 line as a stretch run contributor, and we know why Brian Walton nabbed the flychaser.
Round 5. Gleyber Torres (Yankees, 3B): Torres, who turns 20 next month, was rumored to be the best looking prospect at the AFL where he hit a cool .403-3-11 with a .513 OBP and 1.158 OPS. He may be a long shot for third with the Pinstripes, but the rebuilding team does not have a lot to lose giving the kid a shot depending upon how he fares at Double-A. Eric Longenhagen figures that Torres, who has a .282-16-163 line with 53 steals and a .356 OBP over two minor league seasons, is going to be the go-to guy.
Round 6. Francis Martes (Astros, P): Again, a rotation with some question marks despite the presence of a Cy Young guy a couple of years back. Martes, just 21, rocked it pretty well at Corpus Christi last year, going 9-6, 3.30 over 125.3 frames, with 131 punchouts. Thus, Jock Thompson, one of the HQ guys, grabbed him.
Round 7. Sam Travis (Red Sox, 1B): I was surprised that ESPN's Eric Karabell grabbed Travis this early, as he was injured the bulk of 2016. That said, the first sacker hit .272-6-29 for the PawSox before a torn ACL ended his season. Travis was successful at Triple-A, and well, then the question is who does Boston have to play first base these days? All of this factored into Eric's smart selection.
Round 8. Cody Bellinger (Dodgers, 1B/OF): No idea where this kid will play, but he can definitely rake, hitting .314-3-17 at the Fall League following a .263-23-65 stint at Tulsa. Like Travis, I wanted Bellinger, but Mr. Longenhagen beat me to the punch.
Round 9. Jacob Nottingham (Brewers, C): I have heard that Nottingham can be tough to get along with, that he has a swing with holes, that he is flat footed, and that catching is not in his future. That said, I have seen him twice at the AFL and once at Spring Training and he has clobbered at least a double plus some other hit, meaning at least six hits over three games, half for extra bases. Since the Brewers have a bit of a hole behind the dish, amongst other places, I think the former Athletic gets a chance to play.
Round 10. Jake Bauers (Rays, OF): Bauers hit .274-14-78 at Montgomery with a solid .370 OBP (73 walks to 89 strikeouts) and could indeed be in the works for the Tampa outfield. At least that is what Jock Thompson thinks, and I suspect Jock might be onto something.
Check in next week when I look at the draft and hold team I assembled as part of a Fantrax NFBC-style tourney coordinated by the inimitable Tim Wagner.
Follow me @lawrmichaels.