Given my day job of covering the St. Louis Cardinals system, I often receive fantasy-related questions about the team from friends. They are frequently industry writers and analysts with whom I may work and even play in leagues against – something I call coopetition (not to be confused with collusion!)
In an earlier article, I discussed how I gave my honest and complete assessment of Marco Gonzales’ injury situation to a friend/competitor. Though my initial offer to acquire the lefty to back up my optimism was turned down, I ended up getting him in a trade a few weeks later.
Since, Gonzales suffered a setback at Triple-A Memphis, leaving me much less optimistic. The problem area has shifted from pectoral muscle soreness to the shoulder. Even though the injury is said to be non-structural, any time a pitcher has a shoulder problem, red flags should go up. In this case, Gonzales will be parked for three weeks, when another assessment will be made.
That leaves the Cardinals rotation spot vacated by Adam Wainwright firmly in the hands of another lefty – oft-injured Jaime Garcia. No stranger to shoulder problems himself, Garcia was activated last week. I was at Citi Field to see his debut in person.
Perhaps my interest level was piqued a bit as my pitching-starved National League Tout Wars squad is at or near the bottom of the league in most pitching categories. As a result, I activated Garcia in Tout ahead of his actual removal from the Cardinals’ disabled list.
Other than control issues at the start of innings, it was a very strong outing for a season debut. Garcia still has his late movement on pitches. He then went from five walks in his first start to none in his second and picked up his first win in almost two seasons.
Even before Gonzales’ setback, the rotation berth was Garcia’s to lose. He has both the contract ($9+ million this season) and the past success to secure that level of commitment from the club.
I believe that Garcia will remain in the rotation unless/until he gets hurt again or for some unknown reason, his performance falls off a cliff. My sense is that there is little middle ground with Garcia. He is either healthy and pitching well or is hurt. As a result, whatever starts he gives should be good.
I cannot affirm how many starts that will be, however, given the ongoing injury risk.
If Gonzales can come back this season and perform well at Triple-A, he will definitely be back with St. Louis in 2015. The only question is the role as there are a number of still-moving parts to consider.
When healthy, Gonzales is clearly next in line for a rotation spot with St. Louis. While Lance Lynn and John Lackey are innings-eaters, the other three in the current starting five have had durability questions – Garcia, Carlos Martinez and Michael Wacha.
In his first extended duty in the rotation, Martinez has been up and down. While that is not surprising coming from most 23-year-olds, St. Louis is in the midst of a pennant race and cannot afford to carry a struggling starter down the stretch.
With setup man Jordan Walden injured, the club does not have a clear answer for Martinez’ old eighth-inning gig to date in 2015. Though an acquisition via trade of an Edward Mujica or John Axford-like arm is more likely - a mid-season move the Cards have done in the past - there could be temptation to push Martinez back into the pen if no suitable answer for the eighth can be found.
Speaking of late-inning relief, has anyone else noticed how Trevor Rosenthal has evolved from a shaky closer in 2014 to one of the most reliable and consistent in 2015? One reason why is his delivery. Once a successful starter in the Minors and likely still harboring a desire to play that role, Rosenthal worked from both the windup and the stretch.
After film analysis, it appeared that the rushing and imbalance that plagued him last season was more prevalent when he was winding up. We have seen the 100 percent stretch-pitching Rosenthal apparently turn the corner in 2015.
Bringing this discussion full circle, the worst case for owners of a healthy Gonzales is that the Cardinals would call Marco up to rejoin the bullpen - as he did late last season. It doesn’t hurt that regular lefties Randy Choate and Kevin Siegrist have been inconsistent.
No matter the role, I would be very surprised if Gonzales remains in the Minors until September - unless he has another physical setback. He still has a long way to go to earn the reputation of Garcia, however.
Brian Walton was the 2009 National League Tout Wars champion, scoring the most points in the league’s 17-year history. He also holds the all-time NL Tout single-season records for wins and saves. His work can also be found daily at TheCardinalNation.com and thecardinalnationblog.com. Follow Brian on Twitter.